Friday, September 14, 2007

Ian McEwan's Atonement


"Briony had her first, weak intimation that for her now it could no longer be fairy-tale castles and princesses, but the strangeness of the here and now, of what passed between people, the ordinary people that she knew, and what power one could have over the other, and how easy it was to get everything wrong, completely wrong."
Those lines above are decisive for everything else that is going to happen in the novel Atonement. Briony Tallis is a 13-year-old girl who is already committed to the life of a writer. The story starts in a hot day in the house of family Tallis, located somewhere beyond London. The romantic minded Briony has written a play - The Trials of Arabella, to welcome her older brother Leon, home. As her 9-year-old twin cousins are coming home due to their parents' split (a scandal in 1935 England), Briony decides to direct the poor things and her 15-year-old ginger-haired cousin Lola on the play, with Briony herself playing the lead character. The first impression you might have of Briony is that she's a spoiled little brat, who annoyingly bosses the poor twins around in endless rehearsals that soon will come out as discouraging, especially when Lola gets the leading role, leaving Briony insecure about the success of her play. Then, she refuses to go on with the act and storms off to her room in tears. But something will happen in between.
From her window, Briony will witness a scene no one else will see in that sultry summer day. In clear lines, she will see her older sister Cecilia who stands on the Triton fountain, undressing to her underwear in front of Robbie Turner, the charlady's son, the boy whose father left earlier and never came back, and whose studies have been sponsored by a generous Mr. Tallis along the years. Robbie has a brilliant future. He wants to go to medical school and nothing seems to stop him on that. Ok. So, suddenly, Cecilia jumps into the fountain bringing back a piece Briony can't clearly see. She witnessed those two figures by the fountain, their acts and facial expressions, but she couldn't hear any of what they said to eachother.
In her fertile imaginative childlike mind, Briony will decide for herself what happened there, it's a turning point in her 13-year-old life. She will misinterpretate what she has seen, she thinks that her poor sister was forced to take her clothes off by that creepy man. From this moment on, the book will get more and more intriguing and it's impossible to stop reading one page after the other.
"This was not a fairy tale, this was the real, the adult world in which frogs did not address princesses, and the only messages were the ones that people sent."
When her big brother Leon arrives with a friend, Paul Marshall, a future millionaire who has recently discovered a formula for chocolate bars, a party is about to begin. Robbie Turner is one of the guests. Once again, Briony will witness alone another scene, this time, in the house's library. She will see her sister making love to Robbie, but please notice, Briony is completely sexually clueless. She thinks the maniac is raping her poor sister. And this time, the two lovers will notice her voyeuristic presence. Now everyone is on the table and dinner is served. In the meanwhile, the twins disappear, they have run away. It's time for leaving the house and looking for the children. It's a hot summer night, the narrative voice never stops mentioning it.
Something more serious will happen. A rape. Lola is raped and Briony is the only one to witness the dark shade of the man who will violate her cousin. She can only hear his moanings. It's the same kind of sound Robbie had made in the library. She's sexually clueless and her writer's imagination is sure of who committed the crime. It was him. It was Robbie. Everyone will believe her. Everyone but Cecilia and Robbie's mother. The lovers are separated. And then, there's time to war. I confess the war lines lacked the same quality as the rest of the book. Sometimes, it even bored me a little, but everything else, with its mix of drama, psychologícal development and thrilling curiosity caught me. Don't get me wrong, i'm very interested in anything that concerns WW2, but in this case, the war itself is nothing but a period of time McEwan will use to develop his narrative and characters.
Written purposely through a self-conscious voice, Atonement is one of the most interesting, well-developed, brilliant, original and nevertheless, greatest novels i've ever read. As many of you know at this point, the book has been adapted to the big screen, and has already premiered for a very selected audience. Something tells me that this film will lack the book's greatness, but let's see.

12 comments:

sara said...

That sounds very good!

yes, the coat would make a wonderful statement during those gloomy days of winter.

x sara o

Kamila said...

Romeika, acabei de ler "Reparação" e já estou com meu texto sobre o livro engatilhado para postar. Adorei ler esse seu texto.

Acho que o que mais me chamou atenção no livro foi a maneira adotada pelo McEwan para contar sua narrativa. Gosto dessa questão de múltiplas visões sobre um mesmo acontecimento. Acho que estas visões são bem contaminadas pelo momento de vida de cada um dos três personagens principais (Briony, Cecilia e Robbie).

Achei o livro belíssimo, denso e emocionante. O epílogo é lindo e o autor brinca o tempo todo com a nossa imaginação.

Livraço, por isso estou ainda mais ansiosa para assistir ao filme.

Bom final de semana!

cotton candy said...

those quotes - the impact upon me...i don't know how to describe it. The impact was so strong. thank you so much for the review!! - I must find the book. ^^

Romeika said...

Kamila, tb me chamou atençao exatamente a mesma coisa, a narrativa é espetacular e as três visões são muito bem amarradas. O epílogo é emocionante e certo acontecimento naquele final é uma pequena bela surpresa do autor que não deixa de ser esperada. Livraço mesmo! Tomara que o filme tenha feito jus à beleza do livro. Bom fds!

Ellie Lee said...

wow! looking at the way u described the book~ it's kinda hard to imagine ANYONE bringing out the true emotions from the book and translating them onto the silver screens.

i'm so gna be reading this=p


anyhow thanks for d comment!! haha! anyhow. i think it's brave of francesca to try out smt entirely diff! the collection is fab!

Kat said...

I saw the film last night(it was released last week here) and it is brilliant. My sister had read the book and thought it was excellent too and very true to it. Ian McEwan is one of the producers so it very accurate. Keira looks amazing, James McAvoy is brilliant and basically everything about the film is great.
Can't wait to read the book.

Kamila said...

Romeika, espero mesmo que o filme faça jus à beleza do livro.

Romeika said...

Sim, Kamila. Acabei de ouvir de uma pessoa (o comentário acima) que realmente o filme é verdadeiro ao livro. Resta esperar! Ansiedade! ^^

FeiraChic said...

I really like your writing. You're truly a journalist. So easy to understand what you say.
Will definetely buy the book.
Nice weekend:)

Romeika said...

Dani, muito obrigada. =) Bom domingo!

cjp said...

Hi Romeika,

I'm glad you enjoyed Atonement, and I enjoyed reading your comments about it. The only part I really disagreed with was your opinion on the Dunkirk section.

WWII is in fact very important to the structure of the novel, as it reflects the terrible consequences of events viewed from different perspectives. Just as, on a micro level, Briony's lies destroy the lives of Cecilia and Robbie, so did Hitler's rhetoric plunge Europe into war. I think it's rather more than just background.

McEwan is a writer who thinks a great deal about setting and event, and how all the pieces of his story relate to one another. It doesn't always work and can seem unconvincing, but Atonement is an example of how impressive an approach it can be.

Romeika said...

Hi Chris, first of all, thanks for reading my text and sharing your opinion here.

I agree with you, the whole WWII happenings are important to the structure of the novel and for what's gonna change in the characters in a way. I just didn't like so much when McEwan described the events surrounding Robbie and the soldiers, with a few exceptions (like that moment when he realizes he wants to have kids despite the presence of horror and death, for example).

When i think of the experience of soldiers in WWII, only a few fictional sources comes to my mind, usually films or a single TV series - Band of Brothers. WWII in Atonement is nothing but a time/place the writer uses to keep on telling the story, i think.

So, i just hope the film didn't bring up all that Hollywood war cliche, with Robbie letting his beard grow.. And i also hope the film didn't explore that "my love, i'm waiting for you" thing too much. The book is much more than a war drama. It's a lifetime drama. And Briony's acts are certainly more destructive for the lovers than any war, as you so well pointed (very good comparisson btw Briony X Hitler).

And i agree on what you said on McEwan, i think he just picked the right History time to tell this story. I loved the book so much, i'm definetely reading other of his books in the future. It's not every day a fictional story brings tears to my eyes:-)